Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in Multi- Brand Retail Trading - Discussion Paper
 
Feedback / Views Received on the Discussion Paper so Far

Feedback Number

Comments Posted / Received

Page No. of the Pdf File

 1

 

 

American Chamber of Commerce in India (AMCHAM India)





Feedback 1

1

U.S. - India Business Council

6

R & A Associates,

13

Kisan -Jagriti Manch

16

Raj Jain <Raj.Jain@wal-mart.com>

24

Merchants' Chamber of Commerce

29

CAIT Maharashtra

36

2

BIMTECH

Feedback 2

1

3

CARREFOUR

Feedback 3

1

4

  

 

Dindigul Groundnut and Seeds Merchants Association











Feedback 4

1

Virundhunagar Dhau Manufacturers & Merchants Association

2

Merchant's Association, Panagudi -

3

Bodinayakanur Merchant's Association

5

Karur District Finance And Chitfunds Association

6

Erode Mavatta Kattida Porutkal Virpanaiyalargal Sangam

7

Simmakkal Fruits (wholesale) Traders Association, Maduri

8

The South India Hosiery Manufacture Association

10

Tamilnadu Butter & Ghee Traders Association,

12

Pollachi Dry Chillies Merciiants Association

13

Agro Food chamber of Commerce& Industry

14

Retailer Association Of India (RAI)

22

Bharitya Majdoor Sangh

27

Agro Food Chamber of Commerce & Industry, Madurai

31

TSR Subramanian

50

Karnataka Stainless  Steel Trade And Industry Association

63

Association of Dental Industry & Trade of India

69

5

  

Federation Of Associons Of Maharashtra

 

 

 

 

Feedback 5

1

Mieco Pumps & Generators Pvt. Ltd.

17

Karnataka Hardware & Allied Merchants Association

18

Nielsen Company

22

Tamil Nadu Oil And Seeds Association

27

Tamilnadu Timber Merchants & Saw Mill Owners Federation

28

The Sivakasi Paper Merchants' Association

30

Tue Poona Merchant's Chamber

31

Paras Bothra [paras_acs@yahoo.co.in]

33

A. Robert Roche', Pondicherry

41

Nag-vidarbha Chamber of commerce

44

Harshal Sanghvi [mailto:harshalsanghvi@gmail.com]

54

Tamilnadu Chamber of Commerce & Industry, Madurai-9, Tamilnadu.

56

Spice Retail Limited

63

Tamilnadu Chamber Of Commerce & Industry

69

Federation of Kanyakumari District Chamber's of Commerce & Industry. (FEKCCI)

76

6

IVCA

 

Feedback 6

1

Trilegal

8

Deloitte Touche- Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.

14

Centre for Management in Agriculture (CMA) Indian Institute of Management (lIM) Vastrapur Ahmedabad-

20

Paras Bothra [paras_acs@yahoo.co.in]

30

7

LEXCOUNSEL



Feedback 7

1

Merchants Chamber <merchantchamber@yahoo.com>

12

Pantaloon Retail (India) Limited

20

CII- Confederation of Indian Industry

36

8

Comments Received various Traders from Bangalore and Mysore

Feedback 8

1

9

Nav Mumbai Merchants Chamber

 

Feedback 9

1

Eric Toy Program Director Coalition of Service Industries

4

Farsheed Patell Dorabjee & Co. Pvt. Ltd.

10

METRO Cash & Carry India Pvt. Ltd

15

All India Ophthalmic Association

20

10

Paras Kumar Jain, Secunderabad, India

 

 

 

 

Feedback 10

1

Dindigul Groundnut and Seeds Merchants Association

8

The Virudhunagar Dhall Manufacturers & Merchants Association

9

Bodinayakanur Merchant's Association

10

Karur District Finance And Chitfunds Association

11

Erode Mavatta Kattida Porutkal Virpanaiyalargal Sangam

12

Simmakkal Fruits (wholesale) Traders Association, Maduri

13

Tamilnadu Butter & Ghee Traders Association

15

The South India Hosiery Manufacture Association

16

Pollachi Dry Chillies Merchants Association

18

Merchant's Association, Panagudi

19

Agro Foodchamber of Commerce & Industry

21

Tamilnadu Chamber of Commerce and Industry

29

Federation of Kanyakumari District Chamber's of Commerce & Industry

36

11

Arun Ojha All India Convenor Swadeshi Jagran Manch

 

Feedback 11

1

P.G. Dept Of Commerce marian college kuttikkanam Kuttikkanam P.O., Peermade -

17

FICCI

24

Coimbatore Maligai(grocery) Merchants Association

29

12

Tamilnadu Chamber Of Commerce & Industry


Feedback 12

1

The Fruit & Vegetable Merchant's Association

3

Surat Vividh·Vepari Mahamandal

10

13

THE TAmilNADU FOODGRAINS MERCHANTS ASSOCIATION LIMITED

 

 

Feedback 13

1

THE MADURAI WHOLESALE GRAINS MERCHANTS ASSOCIATION

3

K K Ram Traiding Corporation

5

Kirorimal Kasiram

7

Rohtakia Traiding Corporation

9

CIGARETTEE DEALERS ASSOCIATION

11

Tamilnadu Consumer Products Stockists Association

12

14

Federation of Karnataka Chambers of Commerce & Industry

 

 

Feedback 14

1

Federation Of Davangere District Chambers Commerce & INDUSTRY

2

President, FICCI

9

Devaram Varthahargal Sangam, Theni

10

Bhopal Chamber Of Commerce & Industry

12

Upbhokta Adhikar Samiti

14

DSCL

15

15

Kanara Small Industries Association  

 

 

 

Feedback 15

 

1

Dr. B. Ram Kumar Professor in Economics (Retd.) Chennai

3

Allen Baby Economist, State Bank of India- Global Markets Mumbai.

11

Sid Jain Chief Cataylst Centre for Unlocking Retailing Excellence, Mumbai

13

Ahilya Chamber of Commerce & Industry

27

Dineshwar Tiwary Janpahal

30

Koteshwar Rao Upputuri

35

Yashwanth [mailto:yashwanthkc@yahoo.comj

38

The Betllil Grain Dealer's Federation

39

NishantJonathan Mathew Jacob [nishantj@stanfo.edu)

41

16

V.N Prasad1 & Perumal Koshy

Feedback 16

1

17

Karnataka Hardware & Allied Merchants Association

Feedback 17

1

18

FDI Watch

Feedback 18

1

19

Confederation Of All India Traders

Feedback 19

1

20

Bharath Shah [mailto:shahbharath@gmail.com]

Feedback 20

1

21

Shri Asitava Sen

Feedback 21

1

22

Professor  Kaliappa  Kalirajan  

Feedback 22

1

23

News paper clipping Shri Vinish Kathuria
Associate Professor, SJM School of Management of IIT Bombay.

 

 

 

 

Feedback 23

1

News paper clipping BS Nagesh,
Vice Chairman Shoppers Stop Ltd.

2

News paper clipping
Ms. Nirmala Sitharaman National Spokesperson, BJP

2

News paper clipping
Govind Shrikhande CEO, Shoppers Stop

3

News paper clipping Praveen Khandelwal
Secretary General Confederation of All India Traders

e-mail
caitindia@yahoo.co.in

4

Allen Baby Economist, State Bank of India- Global Markets Mumbai.

5

FDI Watch

6

News paper clipping
Satvik Verma, Lawyer(Delhi)

12

24

Suyog Agrawal

 

Feedback 24

1

BUSINESS STANDARD
Sunil Jain: Retail therapy

2

Amitayu Sen Gupta

4

Mrs. Pramila Raghavendran

6

25

News paper clipping
Ravi Shingarl

 

 

Feedback 25

 

1

News paper clipping
www.businessline.in

2

News paper clipping

3

News paper clipping
Tania@thehindu.co.in 

4

News paper clipping
Bindu D. Menen

5

26

 

Kumbakonam Chamber of Commerce (Regd)

               

                Feedback 26 

1

Bhopal Chamber of Commerce & Industries

2

Lucknow Management Association

8

Karnataka Small Scale Industries Association (KASSIA)

17

The Grain, Rice & Oilseeds Merchants’ Association

19

Federation of Karnataka Chamber of Commerce & Industry (FKCCI)

32

27

News Paper Clippings (IN HINDI)

Feedback 27

1

28

The Mudura Yarn Merchants Association Ltd.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Feedback 28

 

2

 

The Tamilnadu Chemists & Druggists Association

3

 

Madurai District Diamond, Gold & Silver Jewellery Traders Association

4

 

S. Jawaharlal & Co

5

 

Sivakasi Chamber of Commerce

6

 

Theni District Hotels Association

7

 

Chamber of Commerce & Industries

8

 

South India Match Manufacturers’ Association

9

 

Cigarettee Dealers Association

10

 

Nool Viyaparigal Sangam

12

 

The Madurai Dyes & Chemicals Merchant’s Association

13

 

Thiruthuraipoondi Chamber of Commerce

15

 

Madurai Coffee – Tea Merchant’s Association

17

 

Thevaram Varthakarkal Sangam

19

 

The Tamilnadu Fireworks and Amorces Manufacturers’ Association

21

 

SMP Steel Corporation

22

 

180/96 New No.21/2010 - Iron Traders Association

24

 

Nellai Mavatta Beedi Urpathiyalar Sangam

25

 

The Sivakasi Paper Merchants’ Association

26

 

Madurai Central Market Vegetable and Perishable Commodities Merchants Co-ordinated Association

28

 

Tenkasi Chamber of Commerce

29

 

Chamber of Commerce

30

 

A.. Antony Samy

32

 

Pudukkottai District Chamber of Commerce

34

29

Cheranmahadevi Chamber of Commerce & Industry

 

 

 

Feedback 29

 

1

 

Tamil Nadu Oil and Seeds Association

2

 

Elayirampannai Traders Association

4

 

Tamilnadu Timber Merchants & Saw Mill Owners Federation

6

 

Maligai Vyabarigal Sangam

8

 

Aruppukottai Chamber of Commerce

9

 

Madurai Aluminium Manufacturers & Merchants Association

10

 

Dindigul Chamber of Commerce

11

 

Dindigul Grocery & Food Grains Merchants Association

12

 

Chamber of Commerce & Industries

13

 

Tamilnadu Bakers’ Federation – India

15

 

Tamizhaga Viyaparigal Sammelanam

17

 

Indian Chamber of Commerce & Industry

18

 

The Tailnadu Foodgrains Merchants Association Ltd.

22

 

Shopping Centres Association of India

32

30

Gagandeep Dhanoa – SS Agro Farm

 



Feedback 30

2

 

Dinesh Kumar

3

 

Gagan Dhanoa – Gagandeep Ice and Cold Storage Pvt. Ltd.

4

 

Arvind Royal (Yash Veer Singh

9

 

Delicia Foods India Pvt. Ltd.

10

 

Harbans Singh, Farmer

12

 

Amrik Singh, Farmer

14

 

Mohd Haneef

16

 

Balwinder Singh, Farmer

22

 

Parul Bhatia – Sterling Groceries Pvt. Ltd.

25

31

Abhishek Ranganathan, CFA

 

Feedback 31

11

 

Virudhunagar District Consumer Products Distributors Association

13

 

Chidambaram Merchants Association

14

 

The Hardware Merchants’ Association

15

32

The Tamilnadu Foodgrains Merchants Association Ltd.




Feedback 32




 

2

 

Kirorimal Brahmanand

3

 

The Vellore Dhall Manufacturers Association

4

 

News Paper Clipping (Economic Times dated 23.8.2010)

5

 

UK India Business Council

17

 

Lokadhikar

57

 

News Paper Clipping (Economic Times – 24.8.2010)

58

33

Trisis Corp., 86, DIC Industrial Area, Baddi - 173205,
Distt. Solan, Himachal Pradesh


Feedback 33

 

34

Gadag District Chamber of Commerce & Industry, A.P.M.C Road,
GADAG - 582101, Karnataka

Feedback 34

 

35

Multi Brand Retail to attract $20 Billion by 2015 - By Amit Shanbaug in Mumbai
Kirana is for keeps - By Rudroneel Ghosh


Feedback 35

 

36

Udai S. Mehta, Policy Analyst
CUTS Centre for Competition, Investment & Economic Regulation (CUTS C-CIER), D-217, Bhaskar Marg, Bani Park
Jaipur 302 016, India


Feedback 36

 

 

37

TUTICORIN PORT TRANSPORT & EQUIPMENT
OWNERS' ASSOCIATION, LORRY PARKING AREA ZONE "A", HARBOUR ESTATE, TUTICORIN · 628004





Feedback 37

 

 

 
  THE TAMIL NADU STAINLESS STEEL MERCHANTS
AND MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION (Regd.)
(Regd. No. 256 !71)
#13, RAGHONAYAKOLO ST., Und FLOOR, PARK TOWN, CHENNAI - 600 003.



38

 

 

The Bangalore Wholesale Food Grains & Pulses Merchants' Association (Regd.)
1st Floor, M.G. Complex, APMC Yard, Yeshwanthpur,
Bangalore - 560 022.
 
 

Feedback 38

 

 

 

 

 

Navi Mumbai Merchants' Chamber
Office: Central Facility Building, Ground Floor, Market-I, Phase-II, A.P.M.C. Complex, Turbhe, Navi Mumbai - 400 703.
Tel.: 2765 1217

39

Retail Needs FDI Therapy - The Economic Times

Feedback 39

 

40

Maharashtra Economic Development Council (MEDC)

Feedback 40

 

41

Confederation of All India Traders,
(An Apex Body of All Trade Associations & Federations)
Vyapar Bhawan, 925/1, Naiwala, Karol Bagh, New Delhi


Feedback 41

 

 

42

Federation of Rajasthan Trade and Industry
Raniganj Chamber of Commerce & Others

Feedback 42

 

43

Rajasthan Khadya Padarth Vypar Sangh,
B-20 First Floor, Nai Anaj Mandi, Outside Chandpole,
Jaipur 302001

Feedback 43

 

44

Feedback from DSCL

Feedback 44

 

45

Feedback from Dr. Vinay Bharat-Ram, Chief Executive Officer, DCM Limited, Chairman, Shri Ram Centre for Industrial Relations and Human Resources and visiting professor of Economics at IIT, Delhi


Feedback 45

 

46

Feedback from Kanyakumari District Chamber of Commerce & Industry, Swamy & Co, 198, Asambu Road, Vadasery, Nagercoil, Kanyakumari District, Tamil Nadu
Federation of Association of Maharashtra

Feedback 46

 

47

Feedback from Chamber of Small Industry Associations, Member, National Board of MSMEs

Feedback 47

 

 


Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion, Ministry of Commerce & Industry